Tag Archives: control panel

Custom vs Standard Control Panels

Custom vs. Standard (Part 2): Not All Custom Control Panels Carry the Same Margin Risk

Custom could mean a lot of things. Do it all the time, it becomes standard. Never done before, it’s custom.

For this context, let’s look at custom from the panel builders view, not the end application. The custom system will be ‘Engineered to Order. Engineering time is quoted on the job. It also doesn’t roll down the line exactly like the previous (or next panels).

Custom vs Standard Control Panels
Engineered to Order panel have engineering hours billed to a project. For  lower volumes ( generally, sometimes one-off’s) it’s a larger component of the cost/price.

We split these custom categories into two.

The Two Types of “Custom” (And Why Their Margins Differ)

The Domain Specialist (Configured ETO): If a panel shop builds custom municipal water/wastewater packages every week, every panel is technically engineered-to-order, but the shop is building from a reservoir of institutional knowledge and precedent designs. The estimators know the pitfalls, the shop floor staff know the component quirks, margins are protected.

The Clean-Sheet Builder (True Prototype ETO – First-of-Kind): When a shop bids on a one-off machine architecture or an unfamiliar industry spec, the build requires an R&D effort. This is where unbilled engineering hours, scrap materials, and test-bay delays could eat project margin.

Standard panels generally have: off-the-shelf parts, automated wire machines, quick assembly, and rapid cash flow. Custom panels break from that. When a shop loses money on a custom build, it is usually not material costs—it is generally operational costs.

Where the Margins Get Burned

1. Upfront Design & Quoting

  • Unbilled Engineering: Standard jobs use proven drawings. Clean-sheet custom jobs require real engineering time upfront just to model clearances, run thermal calculations, and verify UL 508A Short-Circuit Current Ratings (SCCR) before anyone orders a single part.

  • Customer Vendor Lists (AVLs): When a spec forces a builder to use an unfamiliar vendor list, they lose their bulk volume pricing and get saddled with long-lead items they can’t easily swap out.

2. Cash Flow & Procurement

  • Tied-Up Capital: Builders cannot rely on shelf stock. The Bill of Materials often includes high-dollar, non-returnable components—specialty communication gateways, custom-punched enclosures, or large breaker accessories—that tie up cash while waiting on late deliveries.

  • Milestone Billing Delays: Standard panels get invoiced the day they ship. Custom jobs often trap final payments behind submittal approvals, change orders, and witnessed sign-offs.

3. Shop Floor Costs

  • Tough Fabrication: Machining 316 stainless or punching cast-aluminum NEMA 7/9 explosion-proof enclosures destroys standard tooling and slows production to a crawl.

  • Manual Muscle: Custom design may have parts that have to be fabricated.  Technicians may have to cut, bend, deburr, and torque things manually.

  • Engineering Interruptions: Wire technicians cannot run on autopilot. They might need design engineers out on the floor redlining drawings and sorting out physical clearance clashes.

4. Testing & Floor Space Lockup

  • Test Bay Deadlock: A standard panel takes an hour to test and crate. A custom multi-door lineup can hold a high-voltage test bay hostage for weeks during customer-witnessed Factory Acceptance Testing (FAT).

  • Documentation Overhead: Custom builds demand massive paperwork packages—point-to-point check sheets, torque logs, and detailed QA records.

Bottomline:

Custom panels can bring in higher profits, but the risk profile is higher. The key is knowing which type of custom job you’re bidding. Building a familiar system is great business; taking on a clean-sheet prototype without pricing in the engineering, floor labor, and testing will eat into margin. It can be done, it just requires more research, background knowledge and up front planning.

Share

Top 5 Control Panel Insights – From Industrial People

This week, I reviewed the most engaging industrial control panel threads on r/plc and used a Gemini prompt to aggregate the community’s best advice:

  • Thermal Management: To prevent premature failure from rising heat, avoid placing heat-sensitive devices above heat-generating ones like Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs). This seems obvious, but nuances exist—I will expand on this in a deeper dive later.

  • The “25% Expansion Rule”: Always leave 25–30% open space on back panels and DIN rails. This allows for future system modifications without requiring a full cabinet replacement.

  • Back Panel Labeling: Mount component labels directly to the mounting plate rather than wire duct covers. This ensures technicians can still see the labels during maintenance, and prevents them from getting lost when someone removes the duct covers.

  • EMI Mitigation: Maintain strict physical separation between high-voltage AC power and low-voltage DC control signals to prevent electromagnetic interference. You cannot ignore this rule. It is like smoking cigarettes: EMI will be the diagnosis for all future mysterious ailments of the system.

  • Hinge Wire Management: Use “S” or “U” shaped service loops at door hinges so wires twist rather than pull, which prevents mechanical fatigue.

Next week, I will update these bullets with links to deep-dive posts—especially for points 1 and 4.

Share

Control Panel Layout: Top Tips with some Photos

Amongst the control panel layout tips out there, some are practical, many are good and some are downright weird. There are is a wealth of it in the /PLC sub-reddit. Some of it is amusingly opiniated:

 

The following is my collection of top tips on control panel layouts. A few of the panel posts from Reddit are embedded below. Will add more pointers as I come across them.

 

Busbar candy
byu/Otherwise_Feed_3320 inPLC

1. Heat rises

Do the heat calculations. Enclosure vendors usually have free tools for this like this .

    • If ventilation is needed, fan at the bottom, exhaust at the top, not the other way around. Hot air rises and leaves the panel, cool air comes in the bottom.

2. Power protection components at the top. Circuit breakers, disconnects. The temperature rating on circuit breakers are usually higher than the average PLC, drive or anything that has electronics for that matter. Example here – 30A breaker from SE has an operational ambient of 158 degF/70 degC. Accessibility and safety is also better with power devices at the top. 

3. Incoming power. This really depends on the install site/location. If you have a choice, some would argue that’s it’s better for incoming power to come in from the bottom. With gravity, holes and inlets at the top of the panel have poor contingencies in the event of condensation or dirt coming in( or even water ingress- say NEMA 4/4X failure situations) . 

4. Wire labels, terminals, and wire markers

    • Avoid putting the label on the device. If the device gets replaced, the label goes with it.
    • Sometimes end users may require label on device also. Check before it gets to the FAT
    • Harmonize labelling such that it can be traced back to schematics. This will help with maintenance folks and any troubleshooting efforts.

5. Wireway

    • Vertical runs should intersect with a horizontal run such that the horizontal run stops the vertical cover from sliding down
    • Plan it out such that control wiring is separated from power wiring. If they intersect, make it perpendicular.
    • Read on to number 6.

6. Electromagnetic interference

      • Separate 480Vac and  24Vdc ( control and communications) wires. 
      • If they have to cross, it’s best done perpendicularly- ie. they cross at a 90 deg angle. Still avoid having them in proximity. Good explanation of this here
      • Additional sleeving or barriers for EMI mitigation if needed.

 

7. Spacing If the project allows for it, allow for some room between devices, PLC’s, drives, power supplies. This helps with maintenance accessibility. Also, it makes way for future expansions. More I/O if the PLC needs it, another drive …etc..

My new office 😉
byu/adi_dev inPLC

8. Ground connections

    • Spec grounding washers installed and properly torqued to bite through the paint

9. Network cabling

  • Use pre-terminated cables where possible. From a good vendor, reliability is better. 
  • From item 6 above, separate controls communications cables from the power wiring.

10. Maintenance and usability

  • Add a rack on door for reference material

 

“I´m tired boss…”
byu/andisosh inPLC

Will come back and add more as I find it…

 

Share